How do you adjust hop weight for a different alpha acid?
Bitterness comes from alpha acid, and alpha acid is weight × AA%. So to get the same bitterness from a hop with a different alpha, keep the product the same:
Use the alpha-acid figure for your lot and compare aroma separately. Yakima Chief's Cascade profile, for example, lists an alpha range, oil characteristics, and aroma descriptors; matching alpha acid alone does not reproduce that profile.
your weight = recipe weight × recipe AA% ÷ your AA%
A recipe calls for 40 g at 4.0% and your packet says 4.6%: 40 × 4.0 ÷ 4.6 = 34.8 g. One ounce of 6% Cascade replaced with 10% Centennial: 0.60 oz. Because the IBU formulas scale linearly with alpha acid, matching alpha at the same boil time and volume matches IBUs exactly — Tinseth, Rager or any other. (Some guides call the product "AAUs" or "HBUs"; it's the same arithmetic.)
Alpha acid varies by lot and can fall during storage. If 10% hops are now 8%, they need 25% more weight to match the calculated bittering contribution. Read the lot's AA% rather than assuming a typical value. For older hops, the hop freshness calculator estimates storage loss with its assumptions shown; a current lot analysis is better evidence than subtracting an arbitrary point or two.
When you should not match by alpha
Updated November 4, 2026: replaced the arbitrary storage deduction with a sourced estimate and a current-analysis recommendation.
Late additions are there for aroma and flavor, which come from the hop oils, not the alpha acids — and oil content doesn't track alpha. Swap a 5-minute ounce of 6% Cascade for 0.6 oz of 10% Centennial "to match the alpha" and you've cut the aroma nearly in half for a bitterness contribution that was a couple of IBUs anyway. For anything under about ten minutes, whirlpool or dry hop, use the recipe's weight and pick a hop that smells right. Between 10 and 30 minutes it's a judgment call; the calculator splits the difference and tells you.
No two varieties are the same hop. The chart below groups them by family so a swap keeps the beer recognizably itself; the notes flag the ones that don't really have a stand-in. If a recipe is built around a single hop's character — a Citra pale ale, a Saaz pilsner — expect a good beer that isn't quite that beer, and don't blame the arithmetic.
Hop substitution chart
Common swaps by aroma family, with typical alpha-acid ranges. Adjust the weight with the calculator above.
| Hop | Typical AA | Substitutes | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| citrus/tropical | |||
| Cascade | 4.5–7% | Centennial, Amarillo, Ahtanum | |
| Centennial | 9–11.5% | Cascade, Chinook, Columbus | "Super Cascade" — Cascade at about half the weight for bittering |
| Amarillo | 8–11% | Cascade, Centennial, Simcoe | |
| Citra | 11–13% | Mosaic, Galaxy, Simcoe | no true match; Mosaic is closest |
| Mosaic | 11–13.5% | Citra, Simcoe, Galaxy | |
| Galaxy | 13–15% | Citra, Mosaic, Nelson Sauvin | passionfruit character is hard to replace |
| pine/resin | |||
| Simcoe | 12–14% | Amarillo, Mosaic, Summit | |
| Chinook | 12–14% | Columbus, Northern Brewer, Nugget | |
| Columbus / CTZ | 14–16% | Chinook, Nugget, Magnum | dank; Magnum only for bittering |
| clean bittering | |||
| Magnum | 12–14% | Warrior, Columbus, Nugget, Horizon | |
| Warrior | 15–17% | Magnum, Columbus, Nugget | |
| Nugget | 12–14% | Magnum, Columbus, Chinook | |
| Northern Brewer | 8–10% | Perle, Chinook, Magnum | woody/minty; the California common hop |
| noble/spicy | |||
| Perle | 7–9.5% | Northern Brewer, Magnum, Hallertau Mittelfrüh | |
| Hallertau Mittelfrüh | 3.5–5.5% | Liberty, Mt. Hood, Tettnang, Hersbrucker | |
| Tettnang | 3.5–5.5% | Saaz, Spalt, Hallertau Mittelfrüh | |
| Saaz | 2.5–4.5% | Sterling, Tettnang, Lublin | Sterling is the US stand-in |
| earthy/English | |||
| Fuggle | 3.5–5.5% | Willamette, Styrian Golding, East Kent Golding | |
| East Kent Golding | 4.5–6.5% | Fuggle, Styrian Golding, Progress | |
| Styrian Golding | 4.5–6% | Fuggle, East Kent Golding, Willamette | a Fuggle, botanically |
| Willamette | 4–6% | Fuggle, Styrian Golding, East Kent Golding | |
| unique | |||
| Nelson Sauvin | 11–13% | Galaxy, Motueka | white-wine character; substitutes are loose |
Ranges and swaps as commonly listed in growers' variety guides (Yakima Chief, Hop Union) and the BJCP guidelines — approximate; the packet wins. Match bittering additions by alpha (calculator above), aroma additions by weight.